New Decision On New York Driving While Intoxicated Trial Practice By Michael Joseph on March 19, 2010

A new an innovative tactic among New York criminal defense attorneys who defend driving while intoxicated charges is to challenge the breathilizer records based upon the Sixth Amendment’s right of confrontation. A recent decision gives New York criminal defense lawyers a new weapon in the fight against driving while intoxicated (DWI) charges.

There is a conflict between the Sixth Amendment which gives the accused the right to confront the witnesses against him and New York’s business record rule which allows records into evidence based upon a certification. Typcially in a New York driving while intoxicated (DWI) trial, the prosecutors will just offer the breathilizer records into evidence based on the certificate, without calling the operator. This deprives the criminal defense lawyer from being able to cross examine the operator and thereby challenge the reliability of the breathilizer’s reading.

In People v. Carreira, 893 N.Y.S.2d 844 (N.Y.City Ct.,2010), the Court held that in DWI cases both the simulator solution and calibration records are testimonial for Sixth Amendment purposes and therefore inadmissable unless the New York prosecutor presented live testimony from the person who prepared them. The court went on to note that the business records exception does not appy where the regularly conducted business activity is the production of evidence for use at trial.

The Court also stated that the Confrontation is designed to weed out not only the fraudulent analyst, but the incompetent one as well. Serious deficiencies have been found in the forensic evidence used in criminal trials. One commentator asserts that “[t]he legal community now concedes, with varying degrees of urgency, that our system produces erroneous convictions based on discredited forensics.

Related to This

The Law Office of Michael H. Joseph, PLLC

Law Office of Michael H. Joseph, PLLC

The Law Office of Michael H. Joseph, PLLC, has been helping injured victims recover compensation for their injuries for over a decade. Our attorneys are members of several prestigious organizations, including: 

  • New York State Trial Lawyers Association
  • American Association for Justice
  • New York County Bar Association
  • Westchester County Bar Association

To request your free initial consultation with our team, call our New York City office at (212) 858-0503 or our White Plains office at (914) 574-8330. You can also request a case review online.

Contact Us Today

Rate, Review & Explore

Social Accounts Sprite
Google map image of our location in 18 W 33rd St Ste 400 New York, NY

New York Office

18 W 33rd St
Ste 400
New York, NY 10001

Open Today 8:30am - 6:00pm

Google map image of our location in 203 E Post Rd  White Plains, NY

White Plains Office

203 E Post Rd
White Plains, NY 10601

Open Today 8:30am - 6:00pm

(212) 858-0503 Send a message